Posted on August 29, 2007 - by Justin Hartman
Is Social Media dead?
Hey, it looks like you're new here to my blog! You may want to consider subscribing to my RSS feed and you'll automatically get notified when I post a new blog entry. If web feeds aren't your thing then why not join my email list by clicking here. Thanks for stopping by.
In today’s Blogumist column in The Times Paul Jacobson has written a piece titled Social Media is dead. Paul is a friend and a colleague but I have to say this article spurred some very negative reactions in me and I just think that this article is so far from the truth it’s scary.
Paul argues that
“Although Social Media is only just picking up steam here in South Africa, if you read the feeds on blogs and news sites in the United States and Europe it is fairly obvious that the whole thing is running out of steam.”
Now I’m not sure what news sites Paul is subscribed to but the ones I read tell the exact opposite but don’t take my word on it, let the evidence talk.
Robert Scoble, A-List blogger and Vice President of Media Development at PodTech.net, recently argued that social media sites Mahalo, TechMeme, and Facebook are going to kick Google’s butt in four years.
Michael Arrington, another A-Lister and owner of the popular Techcrunch blog, also linked to Scoble’s article and points out that
Scoble argues that the search results from sites such as Mahalo will appeal to more people due to their ability to be socially constructed as opposed to Google’s computer generated results.
While Arrington doesn’t necessarily agree with Scoble he’s also not disagreeing with Scoble’s thinking.
I’m pretty sure that while these are some good examples that Social Media is here to stay many will say that this only relates to the ever changing face of search and doesn’t really equate to any level of social networking or social media.
Silicon Valley start-up investor Esther Dyson appeared on the Charlie Rose show where she discussed her current projects in the technology space. During this interview she was asked if Facebook is the new Google and to that Dyson replied
“[It is] if you think Google is the next Microsoft.†So, is Google the new Microsoft? Dyson said, “It could well be.â€
From my perspective I have to say that Social Media is changing the way we communicate on a global level. Search is becoming more relevant because of social media and will continue to do so for many years and social media sites are giving us a platform to communicate, share and evolve.
Paul goes on to claim that
All the new launches are reinventions of Social Media companies that have been around for years now or are simply new applications of existing tools. There is no real innovation in this space. Social Media has climaxed. It is all downhill from here.
Facebook’s recent emailing capabilities allow users to now replace traditional email communication and their Book Swap feature highlights how social media can relate to real-world practical uses so I’m just not sure about this statement either.
Is Social Media dead? I think not.
I am the MD and co-founder of 
Visit My Website
August 29, 2007
Permalink
I think William Gibson (http://www.williamgibsonbooks.com/index.asp) probably has a broader perspective on this one.
In a conversation over at RadioOpensource.org he makes a comment about the ‘disappearance of the virtual’. He explains how in the past we had little cyberspace and more of the real world and, how all of that has changed to the level where everything happens on the net. The strangness and newness of the net is slowly dissapearing and soon speaking in terms of the NET and Real world would become meaningless.
In a similar way, I see the disappearance of Social Networks not so much so the disappearance but merely a slow assimilation and migration to something much bigger.
I have mental images of this magnificent CGI rendering of a scene where you are viewing molecules moving round and round and as you zoom out you begin to see hundreds upon thousands of them as they get smaller and smaller, soon you are at magnify level where you realise you are looking at a primitive single cell organism like the amoeba and as you continue reducing the magnification level that single cell view zooms out and you see other cells and soon you realise you are looking at what appears to be neurons connected to each other and forming a pathway, no, a network of pathways.
In a similar way I think this is what is happening on the web.
Visit My Website
August 29, 2007
Permalink
Quincy I think I agree with you as well. The argument for me is not if Social Media is dead but rather what will it become and I think that would a good argument.
It’s part of what Scoble was on about and I think he has a point. The idea that all these social networks will ultimately lead into the greater flow of data and profiling is the most interesting for me. This will propagate itself into search, advertising and marketing and through communication and it’s happening as we speak(write).
Visit My Website
August 29, 2007
Permalink
I think William Gibson (http://www.williamgibsonbooks.com/index.asp) probably has a broader perspective on this one.
In a conversation over at RadioOpensource.org he makes a comment about the 'disappearance of the virtual'. He explains how in the past we had little cyberspace and more of the real world and, how all of that has changed to the level where everything happens on the net. The strangness and newness of the net is slowly dissapearing and soon speaking in terms of the NET and Real world would become meaningless.
In a similar way, I see the disappearance of Social Networks not so much so the disappearance but merely a slow assimilation and migration to something much bigger.
I have mental images of this magnificent CGI rendering of a scene where you are viewing molecules moving round and round and as you zoom out you begin to see hundreds upon thousands of them as they get smaller and smaller, soon you are at magnify level where you realise you are looking at a primitive single cell organism like the amoeba and as you continue reducing the magnification level that single cell view zooms out and you see other cells and soon you realise you are looking at what appears to be neurons connected to each other and forming a pathway, no, a network of pathways.
In a similar way I think this is what is happening on the web.
Visit My Website
August 29, 2007
Permalink
Quincy I think I agree with you as well. The argument for me is not if Social Media is dead but rather what will it become and I think that would a good argument.
It's part of what Scoble was on about and I think he has a point. The idea that all these social networks will ultimately lead into the greater flow of data and profiling is the most interesting for me. This will propagate itself into search, advertising and marketing and through communication and it's happening as we speak(write).